HMO vs PPO at a glance
Averages for one person with job-based coverage in 2025, from the national employer survey.
| HMO | PPO | |
|---|---|---|
| Yearly premium, total | $9,229 | $9,818 |
| Your share of the premium | $1,299 a year | $1,514 a year |
| Plans with no deductible | 47% | 12% |
| Deductible, if there is one | $1,649 | $1,337 |
| Primary doctor copay | $26 | $27 |
| Pick a primary doctor | Usually required | Not required |
| Referral for a specialist | Usually required | Not required |
| Doctors outside the network | Not covered, except emergencies | Covered, at a higher cost |
| Emergencies anywhere | Covered at in-network cost | Covered at in-network cost |
- NetworkThe doctors and hospitals that have a contract with the plan.
- ReferralYour primary doctor's OK to see a specialist.
- PremiumWhat the plan costs each year or month, whether you use care or not. Your share usually comes out of your paycheck.
- DeductibleWhat you pay each year before the plan pays most costs.
PPOs are the most common job-based plan: 46% of covered workers have one, against 12% in HMOs (the survey counts EPOs with HMOs) and 33% in high-deductible plans.
Which costs less, an HMO or a PPO?
For one person, usually the HMO. Its premium is lower, and 47% of HMO plans have no deductible at all. But when an HMO does have a deductible, it averages $312 more than a PPO's, so a year with a lot of care can flip the answer.
Families are different. The average worker's share of a family premium was $7,075 a year for a PPO and $7,680 for an HMO. Employers often pay more toward the PPO, so compare your own paycheck amounts, not the plan type.
Copay or deductible? Many plans charge a flat copay for a doctor visit. If yours applies the deductible instead, you pay the full price your insurer agreed with the doctor until the deductible is met. For a regular visit, that is $45 to $148, from insurers' own price files. Doctor visit cost.
What does a visit cost on your plan?
Tell us your insurance and your city. We'll show what doctors near you are paid on your plan, and what you'd owe.
Get my exact priceWhat happens if you see a doctor outside the network
This is the biggest practical difference between the two.
On an HMO or EPO
The plan usually pays nothing for a planned visit outside the network. You pay the doctor's full charge yourself.
On a PPO
The plan pays part, usually after a separate, higher out-of-network deductible. The doctor can also bill you the difference between their price and what the plan pays. That is called balance billing.
If you need to keep a doctor outside the network
- A therapistCheck each plan's directory, then ask the therapist which plans they take. If they are out of network, an HMO pays nothing for the sessions; a PPO pays part. Ask the therapist their self-pay price per session to compare.
- A specialist in another stateAn HMO usually covers only its own area. A PPO with a national network may count the specialist as in network. Ask the specialist's office which plans they take.
- No one in the network can treat youAn HMO can approve an out-of-network specialist when no network doctor can provide the care. Ask the plan for that approval in writing before the visit.
Emergencies are protected on every plan. Under the No Surprises Act, emergency care at an out-of-network hospital is covered at your in-network cost, with no prior approval. Your rights.
EPO and POS plans: the in-between options
Two more plan types mix the HMO and PPO rules. The letters on your plan card tell you which rules you have.
| Type | Doctors outside the network | Referral for a specialist |
|---|---|---|
| HMO | Not covered, except emergencies | Usually needed |
| EPO | Not covered, except emergencies | Usually not needed |
| POS | Covered, at a higher cost | Usually needed |
| PPO | Covered, at a higher cost | Not needed |
A high-deductible plan can be any of these types. How high-deductible plans work.
Which should you pick?
An HMO fits if
Your doctors are in its network, you are fine seeing a primary doctor first, and you want the lowest premium for one person.
A PPO fits if
You want to keep a doctor who is outside the HMO's network, see specialists without a referral, or get care often in another state.
Then add up a whole year for each plan: your share of the premium, plus what you expect to pay for care. How to compare plans, step by step.
Is my doctor in the network?
Check before you pick. Look the doctor up in each plan's directory, then call the office and ask: "Do you take [the exact plan name] for next year?" One insurer can sell an HMO and a PPO with different doctors. How to check a doctor's network.
Common questions
How is an HMO different than a PPO?
An HMO covers care only from doctors in its network, except emergencies, and usually needs a referral from your primary doctor to see a specialist. A PPO also pays for doctors outside its network, at a higher cost to you, and needs no referral.
What is the downside of a PPO?
It usually costs more. For one person, the average job-based PPO premium was $9,818 a year, against $9,229 for an HMO. Out-of-network care also costs more than in-network care, and the doctor can bill you the difference above what the plan pays.
What is the downside of an HMO?
You need to stay in the network and usually get a referral before seeing a specialist. If you see a doctor outside the network for anything but an emergency, the plan usually pays nothing.
Do doctors prefer HMO or PPO plans?
Many doctors take both, but not every doctor is in every network. A doctor can take one insurer's PPO and not its HMO. Ask the office about your exact plan name, not just the insurer.
What does HMO-POS mean?
It is an HMO with a point-of-service option: you can see some doctors outside the network for a higher cost. It is common in Medicare Advantage. A POS plan usually still needs referrals.
What is the difference between a PPO and a POS plan?
Both pay something for out-of-network care. A POS plan usually needs you to pick a primary doctor and get referrals; a PPO does not.
What is an EPO?
An EPO covers only doctors in its network, like an HMO, except in emergencies. But it usually does not need referrals, like a PPO.
Is Kaiser an HMO or a PPO?
Most Kaiser Permanente plans are HMOs: you get care from Kaiser's own doctors and hospitals. Kaiser sells some PPO and POS plans in some areas, so check the plan name.
Is an HMO or PPO better for a family?
Look at your share of the premium, not the total. On job-based family plans, the average worker paid $7,075 a year for a PPO and $7,680 for an HMO, so the PPO was the cheaper family plan. Your employer's numbers decide it.
Are emergencies covered out of network on an HMO?
Yes. Under federal law, emergency care at an out-of-network hospital is covered at your in-network cost, with no prior approval, on HMOs, EPOs and PPOs.
See what your care costs on your plan
Doctors near you, on your insurance. About 30 seconds. Free. The price at each place comes with a quick email code.
Get my exact priceWhere these prices come from
Federal law requires insurers to publish the prices they agreed with the doctors, hospitals and other places in their network. The prices here come from the June 2026 files. The date on each page is the day its numbers were last checked.
Erin Rose, founder of CareCost. CareCost builds the price tools medical practices use to tell patients what they'll owe before treatment. This site puts the same insurer data in your hands.
Reviewed by Erin Rose, founder of CareCost, on November 11, 2026.
Also: High-deductible health plansHow a deductible worksChoose a health plan