The short version
Four rules of thumb cover most people. The steps below show you how to check them with your own plans.
A high-deductible plan often costs least
You pay less each month and can save in an HSA. Best if you rarely see a doctor.
A copay plan often costs least
Copays let you pay a flat amount per visit instead of the full price until the deductible.
Compare the out-of-pocket maximums
The lower maximum caps your worst year. It can be worth a higher monthly price.
Check your savings first
Tax credits can cut your monthly price. Extra savings on deductibles come only with Silver plans.
Are you choosing at work or on the marketplace?
- Through a jobYour choices are on your benefits website or in HR's open enrollment email. Go to step 1.
- On HealthCare.gov or a state marketplaceDo one thing first: check your savings. Then go to step 1.
Marketplace savings. If your household income is 100% to 400% of the federal poverty level, a tax credit can lower your monthly price. HealthCare.gov works it out when you enter your income. If a job offers you affordable coverage, you usually can't get these savings. For 2027, "affordable" means your own share for the job's cheapest plan is no more than 10.22% of your household income.
Metal levels. Marketplace plans come in four levels. The level tells you how the costs are split, not how good the care is:
| Level | Monthly price | What you pay when you get care | Often fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bronze | Lowest | The most | Little care expected, want protection from a big bill |
| Silver | Middle | Middle. Less if your income qualifies for extra savings | Most people who qualify for extra savings |
| Gold | Higher | Less | Regular care or ongoing treatment |
| Platinum | Highest | The least | A lot of care, and rarely offered |
For a typical person, Bronze, Silver, Gold and Platinum plans pay about 60%, 70%, 80% and 90% of the cost of care. You pay the rest.
Step 1: List the care you expect next year
Start with this year. Your insurer's website lists every visit under "Claims." It's the best guide to next year. How to read those claims. Then write down, for each person on the plan:
- VisitsAbout how many doctor, specialist or therapy visits. Count them, because step 4 uses the number.
- PrescriptionsEach drug you take, with its dose.
- Planned careA surgery, a scan, a baby on the way, physical therapy.
- A bad yearAn ER visit, a broken bone, a hospital stay. You can't plan it, but you'll price it in step 4.
Step 2: Check your doctors and drugs on each plan
A cheap plan is no good if your doctor isn't in it. Each plan has a network: the doctors and hospitals it has a deal with. Outside the network, you can pay much more, or the plan pays nothing.
Look up each doctor in each plan's provider list, then call to be sure. Plan lists are often out of date: in federal reviews, 45% to 52% of listed places had at least one mistake.
What to say to your doctor's office: "Do you take [the exact plan name] for 2027? Not just the insurance company, the exact plan." One insurer can sell plans with different networks.
Look up each drug in the plan's drug list, called the formulary. Check the drug is on it, and its tier. A higher tier usually means you pay more. Taking an expensive drug? Help paying for it.
Know the plan type. The letters tell you how the network works:
| Type | Doctors covered | Referral to see a specialist | Monthly price |
|---|---|---|---|
| HMO | Network only, except emergencies | Usually needed | Often the lowest |
| EPO | Network only, except emergencies | Not needed | Usually in between |
| POS | Network, plus some outside care at a higher price | Usually needed | Usually in between |
| PPO | Network, plus outside care at a higher price | Not needed | Often the highest |
A high-deductible plan can be any of these types. How to check if a doctor is in network.
Step 3: Find the plan numbers
Open each plan's summary. Five numbers decide what you pay. Here is what they look like:
An example built from national averages, not a real plan. Every plan has one of these, called the Summary of Benefits and Coverage. Look for it next to each plan.
Write them down for each plan, side by side. HR emails often show only the premium and the deductible. The rest is in each plan's summary on your benefits website. Or ask HR: "Can you send me the Summary of Benefits and Coverage for each plan?"
One rule to know: a high-deductible plan has no copays before the deductible, except preventive care. So every visit costs you its full price until you reach the deductible.
Step 4: Add up what each plan costs for a whole year
Here's how a year of care works on most plans:
- You pay the full price of your care
until what you've paid reaches the deductible. Visits with a copay are the exception: you pay the copay instead.
- Then you pay your coinsurance share,
like 20% of each price. The plan pays the rest.
- You stop once you reach the out-of-pocket maximum.
The plan pays for all covered care for the rest of the year.
You also pay the premium every month, whether you get care or not. So for each plan, add twelve premiums, plus what you'd pay for your care, minus any money your employer puts in your HSA.
Here are two example plans. Their numbers are national averages for one person with job-based coverage, from the KFF 2025 employer survey: the yearly premium share, deductible, visit copay and employer HSA money. A doctor visit is priced at $74 and a therapy session at $87, the middle of what insurers pay places across the country. The survey gives no average out-of-pocket maximum, so each plan uses the legal limit instead: the 2027 Marketplace maximum for Plan A and the 2027 high-deductible plan maximum for Plan B.
Plan A: a typical PPO, with copays
- You pay for premiums in a year$1,514
- Deductible$1,337
- Doctor or therapy visit$27 copay
- Coinsurance after the deductible20%
- Out-of-pocket maximum (the legal limit)$12,000
Plan B: a typical high-deductible plan, with an HSA
- You pay for premiums in a year$1,364
- Deductible$2,609
- Doctor or therapy visitno copay
- Coinsurance after the deductible20%
- Out-of-pocket maximum (the legal limit)$8,700
- Your employer adds to your HSA$690
- A light yearPlan B costs less: $896 against $1,595. The lower premium and the HSA money win when you barely use care.
- A steady yearPlan A costs less: $2,162 against $2,762. With copays, each therapy visit costs $27. On Plan B, each costs the full $87 until the deductible.
- A bad yearPlan B costs less: $9,374 against $13,514. Its lower out-of-pocket maximum caps the damage. It takes $54,652 in prices to reach both maximums.
Now do it with your plans. Use your own numbers and the visits you counted in step 1. Ask one more question: if a bad year came, could you pay the out-of-pocket maximum? If not, the lower maximum is worth paying for.
Step 5: If your plans are from different insurers, compare their prices
Every insurer agrees on its own price with every doctor and hospital. Before you reach your deductible, you pay that whole price. After it, you pay your share of it. Either way, a lower price means you pay less.
This matters when your choices come from different insurers, which is common on the marketplace and at some jobs. Here's what five insurers pay for the same knee MRI at places in Texas:
No insurer is cheapest everywhere, and these are statewide ranges. What matters is what each insurer pays at the places near you. It matters most for care you get again and again, like therapy. Here is what the same five insurers pay for a 45-minute therapy session at places across the country:
The tool above prices your care with each plan's insurer at places near you.
Step 6: Picking a high-deductible plan? Use an HSA
A high-deductible health plan has a deductible of at least $1,750 for one person in 2027. It lets you open a health savings account, or HSA.
- You put money in before taxes.
Up to $4,500 for one person, or $9,000 for a family, in 2027.
- You use it for care.
Deductibles, prescriptions, dental and more. Spent on care, it's never taxed.
- It stays yours.
Unused money rolls over every year, even if you change jobs.
Money your employer adds to your HSA counts as savings. Step 4 subtracts it from Plan B's yearly cost.
Sign up before the deadline
- Through a jobYour employer sets the deadline. It's in your open enrollment email or on your benefits website. Not sure? Ask HR today.
- On HealthCare.govOpen enrollment for 2027 runs November 1 to January 15. Pick by December 15 for your plan to start January 1. Some states run their own marketplace with different dates.
- MedicareMedicare has its own window: October 15 to December 7.
Want a person to help? Trained helpers called Navigators help you compare marketplace plans for free. Find one on HealthCare.gov under "Find local help."
Common questions
Which health insurance plan should I choose?
The one that costs you least for a whole year, with your doctors and drugs covered. Add up twelve premiums plus the care you expect, for a light year and a bad year. Lots of visits usually favor a copay plan. Little care usually favors a high-deductible plan.
Is a high-deductible plan worth it?
Often, if you're healthy and expect little care, especially if your employer adds money to your HSA. If you see a doctor or therapist often, you pay full price for each visit until the deductible, so a copay plan can cost less.
What's the difference between an HMO and a PPO?
An HMO usually covers only doctors in its network and needs a referral to see a specialist. A PPO lets you see doctors outside the network at a higher price, with no referral, and usually costs more each month.
Bronze or Silver: which marketplace plan should I pick?
Bronze costs less each month but pays a smaller share of your care. If your income qualifies for extra savings on deductibles and copays, you only get them with a Silver plan. HealthCare.gov shows whether you qualify.
Should I put my spouse and kids on my plan?
Compare the family price at your job with your spouse's job plan. Children can stay on a parent's plan until age 26, even if they're married or out of the house.
Should I keep the same plan as last year?
Check it again. Prices, doctors and drug lists change every year. If you do nothing, a job plan usually rolls over, and a marketplace plan may renew on its own, maybe at a new price.
Can I change plans later in the year?
Usually not. Outside open enrollment, you can only change plans after a life event like a move, a marriage, a new baby or losing other coverage.
Where these prices come from
Federal law requires insurers to publish the prices they agreed with the doctors, hospitals and other places in their network. The prices here come from the June 2026 files. The date on each page is the day its numbers were last checked.
Erin Rose, founder of CareCost. CareCost builds the price tools medical practices use to tell patients what they'll owe before treatment. This site puts the same insurer data in your hands.
Where the rules and numbers come from
Each rule on this page, and the law or official page it comes from.
- November 1HealthCare.gov 'Dates and deadlines for 2027 health insurance': Open Enrollment for 2027 starts November 1
- January 15HealthCare.gov 'Dates and deadlines for 2027 health insurance': January 15, Open Enrollment ends (some state marketplaces set their own dates)
- December 15HealthCare.gov 'Dates and deadlines for 2027 health insurance': last day to enroll or change plans for coverage starting January 1
- October 15 to December 7Medicare.gov: Medicare Open Enrollment runs October 15 to December 7 each year
- 100% to 400% of the federal poverty levelHealthCare.gov premium tax credit; KFF and CRS R48290: the enhanced credits expired after 2025, so for 2027 credits are generally limited to household incomes of 100% to 400% of the poverty level
- 10.22%IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-26: 2027 employer coverage counts as affordable if the employee's own share for the cheapest self-only plan is no more than 10.22% of household income; then marketplace tax credits are usually not available
- about 60%, 70%, 80% and 90%HealthCare.gov 'The metal categories': Bronze plans pay about 60% of costs for a typical population, Silver 70%, Gold 80%, Platinum 90%
- SilverHealthCare.gov 'Cost-sharing reductions': extra savings on deductibles and copays are only available with Silver plans, for people who qualify by income
- $1,750IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-24: 2027 minimum deductible for a high-deductible health plan, self-only coverage ($3,500 family)
- no copays before the deductible, except preventive careIRS Publication 969: a high-deductible health plan can't pay benefits before the deductible is met, except for preventive care
- $4,500IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-24: 2027 HSA contribution limit, self-only coverage
- $9,000IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-24: 2027 HSA contribution limit, family coverage
- $1,514KFF EHBS 2025 Fig 6.6: worker contribution, single coverage, PPO $1,514
- $1,364KFF EHBS 2025 Fig 6.6: worker contribution, single coverage, HDHP/SO $1,364
- $1,337KFF EHBS 2025 Fig 7.6: PPO $1,337
- $2,609KFF EHBS 2025 Fig 7.6: HDHP/SO $2,609
- $27KFF EHBS 2025 Fig 7.36: average primary care copay, PPO $27
- $690KFF EHBS 2025 Fig 8.7: average annual employer HSA contribution, single coverage, HSA-qualified HDHP $690 (incl. $0)
- the KFF 2025 employer surveyKFF Employer Health Benefits Survey 2025: worker premium contribution for single coverage (Fig 6.6), average single deductible (Fig 7.6), average primary care copay (Fig 7.36), average employer HSA contribution (Fig 8.7). Plan A uses the PPO averages and Plan B the high-deductible averages. Read 2026-11-11
- The survey gives no average out-of-pocket maximum, so each plan uses the legal limit instead: the 2027 Marketplace maximum for Plan A and the 2027 high-deductible plan maximum for Plan B.CMS 2027 Payment Notice parameters guidance (Jan 29, 2026): 2027 Marketplace maximum out-of-pocket $12,000 self-only. IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-24: 2027 HDHP out-of-pocket maximum $8,700 self-only. Same figures as mkt_oop_2027 and hdhp_oop_2027 in constants.yaml. Read 2026-11-11
- 26HealthCare.gov 'Young adult coverage': children can stay on a parent's plan until age 26
- freeHealthCare.gov 'Find local help': trained assisters (Navigators) help at no cost
- 45% to 52%CMS Medicare Advantage online provider directory reviews, rounds 1-3 (2016-2018): 45.1%, 52.2% and 48.7% of listed locations had at least one inaccuracy
Compare your plans for a whole year
Enter each plan's numbers and the care you expect. We price your care near you and add up the year for each plan. Free.
Compare my plans