How to ask for one
- Say the words "good faith estimate."
Front desks know the term. Ask when you schedule, or any time before the visit.
- If you want the self-pay price, say you are self-pay for this visit.
The right applies when you are not using insurance for that care. Decide before the visit: once care is billed as self-pay, you usually can't switch it to insurance afterward, and what you pay won't count toward your deductible.
- Ask that it include the other providers.
For a scan, the reading. For surgery, anesthesia and the facility. Each should be listed with its own charge.
- Keep it.
You need it to dispute a bill that comes in $400 or more higher.
Why ask, if you have insurance
Two reasons. First, the self-pay price is sometimes lower than what your insurer has agreed to pay, especially before your deductible is met. Second, the estimate makes the place commit to a number. Get both numbers before the visit: the self-pay estimate from the office, and the insurer price from the tool. Then pick. Self-pay usually does not count toward your deductible, so a lower cash price can still cost more over a year if you expect more care.
If you use your insurance, the estimate rules are different. The law also promises insured patients an "advanced explanation of benefits" from their insurer before care, but that part is not yet in use. Until it is, the tool shows the insurer's agreed price at each place, which is the number that explanation would start from. Your share on top depends on your deductible and coinsurance.
If the bill is higher than the estimate
- Check the gap.
A provider's bill must be at least $400 more than that provider's part of the estimate.
- Call the provider first.
Many will match the estimate when you point to it.
- Start a dispute within 120 days of getting the first bill.
Through the federal patient-provider dispute resolution process at cms.gov/nosurprises. The fee is $25. If the decision goes your way, it comes off what you owe the provider.
- Know the bill is on hold.
While the dispute is open, the provider can't send the bill to collections or add late fees.
Common questions
Who has the right to a good faith estimate?
Anyone who is uninsured, or who has insurance but chooses not to use it for that care (self-pay). Providers must give it in writing. The law also covers insured patients, but that part is not yet enforced, so if you use your insurance you can ask, and the office can say no.
When do I get it?
If you schedule at least 10 business days ahead, within 3 business days of scheduling. If you schedule 3 to 9 business days ahead, within 1 business day. If the visit is less than 3 business days away, the office does not have to give one. You can also ask for one without scheduling, and get it within 3 business days.
What if the bill is higher than the estimate?
If any provider's bill is at least $400 more than its part of the estimate, you can start a federal dispute. Do it within 120 days of getting the first bill. There is a $25 filing fee. A reviewer decides what you owe.
Does it include everything?
It should list the main service and the other services that usually go with it, like anesthesia or the reading of a scan, with each provider's charge. If something is missing, ask.
Is the estimate the same as the price in your tool?
No. The estimate is the provider's charge for self-pay. The tool shows what your insurer has agreed to pay. Compare both; sometimes the self-pay price is lower.
Sources
The No Surprises Act (Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021), the good faith estimate rules in the federal regulations, and the patient-provider dispute resolution process run by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). Insurer prices on this site come from the files 37 insurers publish under the Transparency in Coverage rule.
Erin Rose, founder of CareCost. CareCost builds the price tools medical practices use to tell patients what they'll owe before treatment. This site puts the same insurer data in your hands.
Also: Your deductibleHospital vs imaging centerWhat care costs
Where these rules come from
Each rule on this page, and the law or official page it comes from.
- January 2022No Surprises Act effective date
- at least 10 business days ahead45 CFR 149.610(b)(1)(vi)
- 3 business days45 CFR 149.610: scheduled 10+ business days out
- 3 to 9 business days ahead45 CFR 149.610(b)(1)(vi)
- 1 business day45 CFR 149.610: scheduled 3-9 business days out
- less than 3 business days away45 CFR 149.610 (no GFE required)
- $40045 CFR 149.620 (patient-provider dispute resolution), CMS
- 120 days45 CFR 149.620
- $25CMS patient-provider dispute resolution administrative fee (45 CFR 149.620(g)); not refundable, but if the decision goes your way it is deducted from what you owe the provider (cms.gov dispute-a-bill)
Know the insurer price before you ask for an estimate
Every place near you, compared on your insurance. About 30 seconds. Free. The price at each place comes with a quick email code.
Check my price